Single carrier vs multi carrier modulation comes down to where the receiver pays for a dispersive channel. A single-carrier system sends one fast symbol stream across the whole bandwidth and needs a long equalizer to undo multipath. Multi-carrier modulation sends many slow streams side by side, so equalization becomes trivial, but the summed waveform has a much higher peak-to-average power ratio.
That trade explains why LTE and 5G NR use OFDM-based multi-carrier waveforms, and why the LTE uplink chose SC-FDMA, a single-carrier variant, to protect the handset power amplifier. This article compares the families. How OFDM itself is built, including the cyclic prefix and numerology, is covered in the OFDM overview.
Single carrier vs multi carrier modulation at a glance
Single-carrier modulation maps bits onto one carrier as QPSK or QAM symbols, as described in the digital modulation overview. The symbol period is roughly the inverse of the bandwidth, so a wide channel means very short symbols. Multi-carrier modulation divides the same bandwidth into N subcarriers and stretches each symbol by about N times.
| Property | Single-carrier modulation | Multi-carrier modulation (OFDM) |
|---|---|---|
| Symbol duration | Short, near 1/bandwidth | Long, near N/bandwidth |
| Multipath handling | Time-domain or frequency-domain equalizer | Cyclic prefix and one-tap equalizer per subcarrier |
| PAPR | Low, set by pulse shaping and constellation | High, grows with random subcarrier addition |
| Frequency offset and phase noise | More tolerant | Sensitive, because subcarriers lose orthogonality |
| Scheduling flexibility | Whole channel, unless filtered | Any group of subcarriers per user |
Advantages of multicarrier modulation
Multi-carrier modulation has three main advantages. The first is that a frequency-selective channel looks flat to each narrow subcarrier. The second is adaptive loading: a transmitter that knows the channel can use dense QAM on strong subcarriers and QPSK on weak ones. The third is flexible multiple access, because users can be assigned different subcarriers within a symbol.
The first advantage is the decisive one for broadband wireless. Its value appears clearly in the equalizer workload, which the next section works through.
Advantages of OFDM over FDM
Classic frequency division multiplexing also sends several carriers, but it keeps them apart with filters and guard bands. OFDM drops the guard bands. Subcarriers are spaced at exactly 1/T, the inverse of the symbol duration, so each spectrum overlaps its neighbours while its peak lands on their nulls, as Figure 1 shows.

The saving is easy to estimate. A 15 ksym/s carrier with root-raised-cosine filtering at a roll-off of 0.25 needs about 18.75 kHz, so an FDM raster would use that spacing. OFDM uses 15 kHz, a gain of 1.25. After charging the cyclic prefix, with 14,000 symbols per second instead of 15,000, the net gain is about 1.17. A second advantage is hardware: an FFT replaces a bank of oscillators and sharp filters.
Worked example: equalizing a 20 MHz channel
Take a 20 MHz channel whose multipath echoes spread over 4 µs of total excess delay (not rms delay spread), a value in the range of an urban macro cell.
- Single carrier: with a roll-off of 0.25 the symbol rate is 16 Msym/s, so T = 62.5 ns. The delay spans 4 µs / 62.5 ns = 64 symbols, which calls for a 65-tap FIR equalizer. At one complex multiplication per tap per symbol the load is 65 × 16 M = 1,040 million multiplications per second.
- OFDM: use LTE-style parameters, with 1,200 subcarriers at 15 kHz, a 2048-point FFT and 14,000 symbols per second. The symbol lasts 66.7 µs, so 4 µs is only 6% of it and fits inside the normal cyclic prefix of about 4.7 µs. An FFT needs (N/2) log2 N = 11,264 multiplications, and each subcarrier needs one more. The load is (11,264 + 1,200) × 14,000 = 174.5 million per second.
The single-carrier receiver does about six times more work, and Figure 2 shows that the gap widens with delay. The OFDM curve is flat because the FFT cost does not depend on the channel. These are counts for a plain FIR structure. A real adaptive equalizer needs training on top of this.

Single-carrier links can avoid this with frequency-domain equalization, adding a cyclic prefix and using an FFT at the receiver. That approach is the bridge to SC-FDMA.
Limitations of OFDM
OFDM’s weaknesses all sit in the RF hardware. The sum of many independent subcarriers behaves like a Gaussian signal, with occasional high peaks, so the power amplifier must back off to stay linear, which costs efficiency. The topic is treated in depth in modulation, EVM and PAPR. Long symbols also make OFDM sensitive to carrier frequency offset and phase noise, which leak energy between subcarriers. Finally, the sinc-shaped subcarrier spectrum decays slowly, so filtering or windowing is needed to meet emission masks.
OFDMA vs SC-FDMA
OFDMA is OFDM used for multiple access, with different users on different subcarriers. SC-FDMA keeps that same structure but adds a DFT before the subcarrier mapping. The DFT spreads each data symbol across all allocated subcarriers, and the IFFT then produces a signal that behaves like a single carrier in time.
- OFDMA transmits each QAM symbol on one subcarrier, in parallel. A subcarrier fade hits a few symbols.
- SC-FDMA transmits symbols in sequence at a higher rate. A fade is spread over all symbols, and the receiver uses a frequency-domain equalizer.
Figure 3 shows what this buys. In a simulation with 300 subcarriers and 4× oversampling, the PAPR exceeded with probability 10-3 is about 11.4 dB for OFDM, 7.8 dB for QPSK SC-FDMA and 8.8 dB for 16-QAM SC-FDMA. The 3.6 dB QPSK advantage translates almost directly into less back-off at the amplifier, which matters most at the edge of the cell in a battery-powered handset. PA linearization can narrow the gap but does not remove it.

DFT-s-OFDM vs SC-FDMA
The two names describe essentially the same signal. SC-FDMA is the LTE term, emphasizing multiple access. DFT-spread OFDM, or DFT-s-OFDM, describes how the waveform is generated, and it is the term used for 5G NR. NR specifies transform precoding as an uplink option next to CP-OFDM, and it is generally used for coverage-limited, low-rank transmission.
OFDM in LTE and 5G NR
LTE, the main 4G standard, uses OFDMA in the downlink and SC-FDMA in the uplink. The split follows the hardware: a base station can afford a large linear amplifier, while a handset cannot. NR uses CP-OFDM in both directions, keeps DFT-s-OFDM for the uplink, and adds scalable subcarrier spacing. The subcarriers in OFDM for NR range from 15 kHz upward, so wider spacing can be chosen for higher bands. RF implications appear in the 5G RF front end.
Choosing a waveform
Use the channel and the amplifier as the two tests. If the bandwidth is wide relative to the coherence bandwidth and the transmitter can afford back-off, multi-carrier modulation usually wins. If the link is power-limited, or the channel is close to flat, a single-carrier waveform often does better. Microwave backhaul and satellite links, with strong line-of-sight paths and amplifiers run near saturation, have long favoured single-carrier modulation.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between single-carrier and multi-carrier modulation?
Single-carrier modulation sends one high-rate symbol stream across the channel. Multi-carrier modulation splits the data into many low-rate streams on separate subcarriers. The first has lower PAPR but needs heavier equalization. The second simplifies equalization at the cost of higher PAPR.
Is OFDM a single-carrier or multi-carrier technique?
OFDM is multi-carrier. SC-FDMA uses the same transmit blocks plus a DFT stage, which gives it single-carrier behaviour in the time domain despite occupying many subcarriers.
Why does LTE use SC-FDMA in the uplink?
Its lower PAPR lets the handset amplifier run closer to saturation, which improves efficiency and extends uplink coverage. The base station handles the extra receiver processing.
Are SC-FDMA and DFT-s-OFDM the same?
For practical purposes, yes. Both precode the data with a DFT before the OFDM modulator. LTE documents use SC-FDMA, and NR documents use DFT-s-OFDM or transform precoding.
Related topics
This comparison sits under RF fundamentals and leads into radio architectures. Read wireless channel fading and OFDM for the channel side of the story.

